Why Customers See Other Businesses First

If ChatGPT recommends a competitor, check whether it can read your page and whether the page answers the customer’s question. Start with one service you sell and one question a customer would ask before buying.

01Why ChatGPT may recommend another business

A customer asking for a recommendation wants to know who can do the job, where they work and why they are a good fit. ChatGPT Search may find clearer answers to those questions elsewhere. Your site might be hard for its search tool to read, your page might leave out a key detail, or a directory might give a clearer description of what you do. For example, a shop owner looking for air-conditioning maintenance needs to know whether you serve shops in their area. A page that only says “air-conditioning services” leaves both the buyer and the search tool guessing.

An answer that leaves you out does not tell you which of these things happened. Use it to decide what to check first.

02Check whether ChatGPT can read the page

OpenAI documents OAI-SearchBot and GPTBot separately. OAI-SearchBot is the software OpenAI uses to find and read pages for ChatGPT Search. GPTBot is a separate tool used for model training. You can allow the search crawler while keeping your existing training preference.

Check your site’s robots.txt file. This is the public file that tells automated tools which pages they can read. Then ask whoever manages the site to check whether your site’s security settings block requests from OpenAI’s listed search crawler addresses. A page that opens in your browser may still show a security check or an error to an automated visitor. OpenAI’s Search guidance describes these access checks and says placement is not guaranteed.

03Ask a question a customer would ask

Suppose an air-conditioning installer in Limassol wants its commercial maintenance page to be found. In a fresh chat with Search enabled, try: “What should a small shop in Limassol check before choosing an air-conditioning maintenance company, and which local providers explain their coverage?” Leave the company name and URL out. Record the date, language, prompt and source links. Open the cited pages and check whether they actually support the answer.

Screenshot of a ChatGPT Search result showing a query about air-conditioning maintenance in Limassol, the generated recommendation, and the open Sources panel, with visual callouts highlighting a business mention alongside its cited domain
A mention and a citation are not the same: ChatGPT may name a business directly in its answer while attributing the recommendation to a third-party directory link.
What you observeWhat to inspect next
Verified crawler requests failCheck the exact page path, firewall rules and response code.
The business appears, but a directory gets the linkCompare the directory’s coverage and contact details with the business’s own page.
A different page on your site gets citedCheck which page actually answers the buying question. Clarify their distinct roles before creating another page.
A competitor appears and you do notCompare coverage, scope and verifiable details on the cited pages. Record the difference as a hypothesis to test.

A successful crawl tells you the page could be read. A citation tells you which page the answer is actually linked to.

A mention and a citation are different

Record the business name and the exact URL in separate columns. If the answer names your business but links to a directory, count it as a mention and record the directory as the cited source.

04Make one change and repeat the test

If the page only says “commercial maintenance”, add information a shop owner can use to decide whether to call, such as the areas covered, the types of premises you serve and what a maintenance visit includes. Use facts your team can confirm. Repeat the same prompt in fresh chats after the updated page is accessible, and retain the original notes so you can compare answers. A changed answer is an observation. One run cannot isolate which change caused it.

If you can’t tell whether the gap is access, relevance or evidence, Studio 17’s SEO and AI visibility work can help narrow down what to investigate first.

A successful crawl tells you the page could be read. A citation tells you which page the answer is actually linked to.

Hugo Filipe